What If Regionals Were Scored The Old Way Part 2: The Men

After Regionals this year, I wondered what applying the scoring system from previous Regionals—pre-2015; the same scoring used in the Open—to this year’s contests would do to the standings. After analyzing how it affected the women’s competition, I applied it to the men’s fields.

East, Central, Meridian: Nothing Changes


East


null

Meridian


null

In the East, Central, and Meridian Regionals, the qualifiers did not change, and neither did their order. Each Region had an athlete who dominated the top of the leaderboard: Matt Fraser (13 total points) in the East; Scott Panchik (36) in the Central; and Bjorgvin Karl Gudmundson (30) in the Meridian. The rest of the top five remained the same.

Central


null

The East’s fourth and fifth sports did get interesting—the old scoring system tallied a tie between Spencer Hendel, Alex Vigneault, and Chase Smith with 69 points—but after the tie-breakers, the placing stayed the same.
In the Atlantic, California, South, and West Regionals, the finishing order of the top five shifted around, but the same athletes qualified regardless of the scoring system.

Atlantic, California, South, West: Similar But Different


Atlantic


null

In the Atlantic, Jacob Anderson (55) jumped into third, which pushed Travis Mayer (57) back to fourth as he sustained more damage from his opening day with 20th- and 15th- place event finishes.

California


null

In the highly competitive California Regional, Josh Bridges (31) dominated, but things got fun after that! Christian Lucero and Rasmus Wisbech Anderson both ended up with 47 points, Lucero took the tie-breaker and moved from fourth into second on the strength of his strict gymnastics with a first in Regional Nate and second in the legless rope climbs. Marcus Filly (48) moved back to the No. 4 spot. After that, there was a three-way tie at 51 points between Garret Fisher, Jason Carroll, and Dan Bailey for the final spot. Bailey, although super-consistent with no finishes outside the top 10, was left out—his best finish was second, whereas Fisher and Carroll both had event wins. Fisher kept the fifth spot; his second-place finish on Day 1’s snatch ladder broke the tie for his second trip to Carson.

South


null

In the South, the biggest change came from runner-up Travis Williams (59), who went from second to fifth as his 29th- and 15th-place finishes in the strict gymnastics workouts, Regional Nate and legless rope climbs, did more damage to his score. The rest of the top five order just shifted up.

West


null

In the West, Lucas Parker (49) and Samuel Kwant (48) swapped third and fourth places, and the rest remained the same.

Pacific: Wait, WHAT


null

The biggest change came from the Pacific men’s competition. Here’s the list of this year’s Games qualifiers from the Pacific in the order they finished with each of their point totals: Rob Forte (51), James Newbury (53), Khan Porter (56), Zeke Grove (61), Mitchell Sinnamon (55). Not listed is this year’s sixth-place finisher Ricky Garard, who would have WON the Region with 50 points if the old scoring system was still used! With the current scoring system, the top six places in each event are separated by 5 points each, but after sixth, it goes down to a two-point spread, meaning seventh and below stay closer in point total to sixth place than the bigger separation among the top five. Garard never finished lower than 13th on any event, but took four sixth-place finishes, which made him the biggest victim of the current scoring system as he could not gain on the leaders or separate as much from the rest of the field. Zeke Grove fell from fourth place due to 19th- and 23rd- place finishes, and would not make the long trip from Australia to Carson.    

After looking at these changes, you can see the differences the two systems bring to the competition and the pros and cons of both. The current system allows home-run hitters to make up for their weaknesses by awarding more points proportionately for wins than it costs for poor finishes. The pro is it makes comebacks easier, which makes the competition more exciting. The con is it allows athletes with weaknesses to pass through to the Games as long as they have major strengths. The previous scoring system rewards consistency much more. A poor finish in a weak event is proportionate to a great finish in a strong event, which makes it tougher for someone with a bad finish to make up ground for a qualifying spot. An athlete who does not necessarily win an event but is in the top 10 on all events will rank better than someone who bombs an event, but can reel off a couple wins in events that line up in their wheelhouse.

An old CrossFit Journal article highlighted the idea that the ideal fitness methodology “punishes the specialist,” but this new scoring system rewards the specialist. Neither is right or wrong—it is a competition, and the athletes play by whatever rules are in place each year. But I believe consistent athletes perform best at the Games, and a system that rewards consistency and punishes weakness may be the best determinant of who best represents each Region at the next level.

Either way you slice it, the Regionals were a blast, and I can’t wait to see this year’s CrossFit Games!

By Neal Kay

Patrick Vellner Talks the Open, 2020 Wodapalooza & More

Patrick Vellner’s season couldn’t have started any better than it did at the 2020 CrossFit Open. He concluded the five weeks as the overall men’s champion. To have the qualification for the CrossFit Games wrapped up so quickly means he has options as to how he moves forward for the rest of the year.

Who To Watch At Wodapalooza 2020: Vellner, Toomey & More

We are just a week away from kicking off Wodapalooza 2020 and to say we are getting excited around here is an understatement. With so many badasses coming to Miami to compete it can be hard to keep up with who to watch and what to keep your eyes open for, but relax — that’s why we’re here. 

Catching Up With Tia-Clair Toomey On 2020 Wodapalooza, Training & More

What separates great athletes from the rest of their field is their desire to stay on top and find that drive to keep competing even when they have nothing else to prove.

James Newbury Talks Confidence For CrossFit

The Australian athlete talks about the importance of mindset.

FloElite To Live Broadcast Leading CrossFit®, Inc. Sanctional™ Events

AUSTIN, Texas (January 23, 2020) - Today, FloSports, the innovator in live digital sports and original content, and Loud And Live Sports announced an expansion of their partnership heading into 2020. FloSports will exclusively stream the Loud And Live Sports events set to occur in the United States, Spain and Mexico. The partnership will bring live and on-demand content and coverage of five high-profile events to a global audience on FloElite. The multi-year deal will include the West Coast CrossFit® Classic, Madrid CrossFit® Championship (Spain) and the Mayan CrossFit® Classic (Mexico) in addition to the Wodapalooza CrossFit® Festival and the Granite Games for which the two had previously partnered. With a prize purse totaling nearly $1.3M USD, these five events have already attracted some of the top athletes within the sport including Tia-Claire Toomey, Patrick Vellner, Lauren Fisher, Noah Olsen, Brooke Wells, Ben Smith and Brent Fikowski among others. 

Why The Open Matters Now & Later

In case you missed the news earlier this week, the scores from the CrossFit Open are now official. The national champions have been crowned and the top 20 are now established. You can see the scores for yourself at the CrossFit leaderboard website. 

Kari Pearce Shares 4 Nutrition Tips For 2020

Many people set fitness-related resolutions around the New Year, and a lot of those people will find their way to the local CrossFit gym with an abundance of motivation and a passion to improve. They will initially get pumped for every workout they go into because of the excitement that comes with getting stronger, faster, leaner, and better overall.

CrossFit Events To Watch In 2020

Your CrossFit calendar for next year is here.

Ben Smith Shares Keys To Recovering From Injuries

Outside of the results of the CrossFit Open, the headlines within the fitness community seem to be dominated by recent injuries of athletes both while training and away from the gym. James Newbury is recovering from a broken back and punctured lung. Sam Briggs suffered a leg injury while attempting Workout 20.4. Thuri Helgadottir also recently announced that she had been training with a type 2 SLAP lesion, which is damage of the labrum near the biceps.

Dani Speegle & The Business Of Making CrossFit A Career

Many of the people who live the CrossFit lifestyle do so as a way to enhance their overall lives and fulfill a personal desire to be their best. They find that training helps them live better lives personally, improve relationships, and even see improvement in results with their careers.